1 / 6
Halloween Would You Rather Cards
Seventy either-or questions about candy, costumes, haunted houses and potions, ten to each color-coded category. The instructions give three ways to play, including a trick-or-treat version where you can act instead of answer.
$2.99
Buy any 3 or more printables and save 20% at checkout.
- Download right after payment — link works for 30 days, up to 5 downloads
- Files arrive as a ZIP with your license PDF inside
- Secure checkout by Stripe · Refund policy
These Halloween would you rather cards pose 70 two-sided questions, from “a king-sized candy bar or 50 fun-size candy bars” to “a witch’s broom or a witch’s spell book.” Each card has a number and a colored category band, so you can pull one theme at a time.
Seven categories, ten cards each
- Trick or Treat: trick-or-treating in the rain or the freezing cold, or finding a toothbrush in your candy bucket.
- Ghosts & Creatures: vampires, zombies, mummies and a witch’s cat.
- Spooky Places: corn mazes, haunted mansions, graveyards at midnight.
- Magic & Powers: broomsticks, potions, magic mirrors and flying carpets.
- Scary vs Silly: carving a happy pumpkin or a scary one.
- Costumes: store-bought or homemade, far too big or far too small.
- Halloween Treats: chocolate eyeballs, caramel apples and bobbing for doughnuts.
Three ways to play
In Classic Circle, one player reads a card, everyone picks a side and explains why. In Trick or Treat, the player who draws chooses a trick (a silly dance, a spooky sound, a monster face) or a treat (answering the question), and the table votes on the best trick. In House of Votes, everyone votes in secret, the reader guesses which side won, and the voting sheet keeps score. Nobody is ever out, and anyone can skip a question by reading the next card instead.
The tips page has separate suggestions for hosts, for kids 6 to 10, for teens and adults, and for classrooms, where the cards can double as writing prompts or speaking practice.
Printing
The cards print four to a page, so the 70 questions take 18 pages. Cardstock holds up to handling, and laminated cards can come back out next October. The card backs are optional: print them on the reverse only if you want a matching back.
